RandomCocconut wrote:

78ch3 wrote:

Other reviews have resulted in unreasonable backlash from staff or shop owners because their shop was underperforming and I hope this does not happen this time around.

“Unreasonable”? You are not rating a shop you are just highlighting the critical flaws. And you should assist the shop right? The federation is called “Scratch Shop Reviews and Assistance Federation” but suggesting to change the banner because it's eyesore (I know that it's eyesore I even wanted to change the banner) it's criticizing you are not helping!

And I don't want that this become an “unreasonable backlash” but I'm just highlight your federation's critical flaws
Excuse me, tell me what's wrong with the tower defense framework? It's like you asked just that the turrets don't move, what's the problem? It's something free, you need to accept free things because If you are asking for code it's because you don't know how to code in a 7 years old coding website.

What critical flaws? You haven't highlighted anything, just that you think pointing out the banner is kinda ugly is not helpful. If you want us to help, we have shops in our federation that can make you a banner. We have services so that we can get you a banner. You haven't pointed out anything wrong with my federation. You don't seem to take away anything from this and just see me as a hostile entity. While yes, it's a harsh review, it still has constructive criticism.

About the TD engine, first of all, I could 100% make my own TD engine if I wanted. Might not be the same as what I asked for, but I'll do it. Second, besides the turret not moving, the enemies do not cycle through costumes when hit, they only have one. The instructions are not the clearest but they do suffice. While I could code these in myself, many scratchers will expect it to be done to completion, even if it's a day or two behind deadline (which didn't exist in this case). These orders are simulating what a shopper could ask for and they test your abilities, they're not because I'm too lazy to make anything. Also, *checks notes* Scratch is nearly 16 years old and has been in development even longer. I wasn't even Scratching for most of my time here.

TKTK1234567 wrote:

I make the banner for your order with canva.

Oh, you did? I wasn't 100% sure but it looked like Scratch editor stuff. My feedback for you in particular is to not use stock images in banners, make sure the text is big and make it high-res (at least 800x400 if it doesn't go in signatures)

78ch3 wrote:

TKTK1234567 wrote:

I make the banner for your order with canva.

Oh, you did? I wasn't 100% sure but it looked like Scratch editor stuff. My feedback for you in particular is to not use stock images in banners, make sure the text is big and make it high-res (at least 800x400 if it doesn't go in signatures)

I got a snip of the singy with an extension to make sure it wasn't to big.

TKTK1234567 wrote:

Activity Check

Lime=Active
Green=Joined Well Activity Check Was Going
Red=Not Active
Yellow=On Vacation Not needed to say active unless you aren't on vacation any more.
Gray=Has Not Replied
TKTK1234567
Myscratchedaccount
zappgame_version3
cs2722201
kinosaurs515
Flip_Gotrice
RandomCocconut
You have 2 Days.

hi there

kinosaurs515 wrote:

TKTK1234567 wrote:

Activity Check

Lime=Active
Green=Joined Well Activity Check Was Going
Red=Not Active
Yellow=On Vacation Not needed to say active unless you aren't on vacation any more.
Gray=Has Not Replied
TKTK1234567
Myscratchedaccount
zappgame_version3
cs2722201
kinosaurs515
Flip_Gotrice
RandomCocconut
You have 2 Days.

hi there

Need to update this do you want to do to do a order?

Activity check here.

78ch3 wrote:

(snipped)

To be fair, I don't think this shop signed up for an unnecessarily long and critical review when they joined the review federation. Besides, you should not leave a really bad review if you're only looking at one order that doesn't really show the quality of the whole shop.

debanane wrote:

78ch3 wrote:

(snipped)

To be fair, I don't think this shop signed up for an unnecessarily long and critical review when they joined the review federation. Besides, you should not leave a really bad review if you're only looking at one order that doesn't really show the quality of the whole shop.

I checked the Federation, they did

debanane wrote:

78ch3 wrote:

(snipped)

To be fair, I don't think this shop signed up for an unnecessarily long and critical review when they joined the review federation. Besides, you should not leave a really bad review if you're only looking at one order that doesn't really show the quality of the whole shop.

I agree thanks for defending us!

TKTK1234567 wrote:

debanane wrote:

78ch3 wrote:

(snipped)

To be fair, I don't think this shop signed up for an unnecessarily long and critical review when they joined the review federation. Besides, you should not leave a really bad review if you're only looking at one order that doesn't really show the quality of the whole shop.

I agree thanks for defending us!

Then, if you want, delete your shop from the Federation or not respond to the activity check

I'm here. I think I might leave because there hasn't been any orders for me

Flip_Gotrice wrote:

I'm here. I think I might leave because there hasn't been any orders for me

Maybe you can do a review order for the shop that is art? This is it:

Username: MyScratchedAccount
Work you want done: art
Description: Banner for my Art123 shops with suprise me!
Are you following the thread: yes
Have you read the TOS?: Figma is a design tool
Other: suprise me (I only need this for reviewing purposes and after I won't need it)

debanane wrote:

Username: debanane
Work you want done: platformer
Description: no art, just 2d non-scrollingfigma
Are you following the thread: yes
Have you read the TOS?: yes
Other:

I am done here it is. Blue = next level red = previous level.

TKTK1234567 wrote:

Activity Check

Lime=Active
Green=Joined Well Activity Check Was Going
Red=Not Active
Yellow=On Vacation Not needed to say active unless you aren't on vacation any more.
Gray=Has Not Replied
TKTK1234567
Myscratchedaccount
zappgame_version3
cs2722201
kinosaurs515
Flip_Gotrice
RandomCocconut
You have 2 Days.

active

TKTK1234567 wrote:

Flip_Gotrice wrote:

I'm here. I think I might leave because there hasn't been any orders for me

Maybe you can do a review order for the shop that is art? This is it:

Username: MyScratchedAccount
Work you want done: art
Description: Banner for my Art123 shops with suprise me!
Are you following the thread: yes
Have you read the TOS?: Figma is a design tool
Other: suprise me (I only need this for reviewing purposes and after I won't need it)

It is a fake shop. It is just so I can see how good it is and leave another review about the order.

New Banner:
https://u.cubeupload.com/ifsodfhh/CourierPrime.gif

https://u.cubeupload.com/ifsodfhh/CourierPrime.gif

Great job on your order!
Speed 4/5
Quality 4/5
Politeness 5/5
Shop Organization 5/5 (woah you have a bump banner?!?!??!?)
Overall Score: 4.5/5

Tips!
The engine was fantastic! It had most of what a platformer engine should have; it's just that the slope physics were a bit clunky, and I felt like there needed to be wall jumping. Remember, quality makes up for lost time. As for your politeness, you are incredibly courteous. Nothing much else to say about that. Your score for Shop Organization speaks for itself, and that's about it! Once again, awesome job. Scratch on!

debanane wrote:

Great job on your order!
Speed 4/5
Quality 4/5
Politeness 5/5
Shop Organization 5/5 (woah you have a bump banner?!?!??!?)
Overall Score: 4.5/5

Tips!
The engine was fantastic! It had most of what a platformer engine should have; it's just that the slope physics were a bit clunky, and I felt like there needed to be wall jumping. Remember, quality makes up for lost time. As for your politeness, you are incredibly courteous. Nothing much else to say about that. Your score for Shop Organization speaks for itself, and that's about it! Once again, awesome job. Scratch on!

That's a great review (removed by moderator - please don't name names)!

RandomCocconut wrote:

debanane wrote:

snip

That's a great review (removed by moderator - please don't name names)!

Ok moderator…